If you may be the person others rely on. You organise, you handle the crisis, you know what to say when someone is upset, and people tell you that you are good at what you do. Privately, you suspect they have been fooled. Each success feels like a narrow escape, and you are waiting for the moment someone notices you were never really qualified.
For many people this pairing of real capability and persistent fraudulence begins in childhood, in a family where they had to act as the adult before they were ready. Knowing where the feeling began explains why reassurance so rarely helps, and why a different kind of test can.
A Feeling, Not a Measurement
Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes described the impostor phenomenon in 1978, drawing on their clinical work with high-achieving women. The people they described felt inauthentic and undeserving despite repeated achievements that demonstrated their competence. They discounted praise and put their success down to luck, timing, charm or someone else’s mistake, and underneath ran a fear of being found out.
Most people now call it impostor syndrome, although it is not a diagnosis. The impostor feeling is a subjective feeling, and it does not track whether you are capable. More achievement does not quiet it, because the feeling was never measuring achievement in the first place.
A Job Taken On Too Early

Children start at a lower level than adults, with less power and fewer skills. The work of parenting is to hold the boundary between the two levels while bringing the child up to become a functional peer. Parentification is what happens when that boundary fails and the child is drawn into the parental level too soon. The demand may be practical, such as running the household or caring for younger siblings, or emotional, such as becoming a parent’s confidant, peacemaker or main source of comfort. The emotional form has consistently proved more costly than the practical one.
A child given an adult role before the brain, the social skills and the practical capabilities are ready produces a childlike version of that role. Ordinarily, a child takes a role on in their own time and improves it step by step. The parentified child is already performing the role, so the early version stays in place. Software offers a comparison: a version released far too early, full of bugs but more or less doing the job, and so never updated. Some parts of the person run that early adult version for life, while the parts that needed care, play and attention stay underdeveloped.
Where the Fraud Feeling Comes From
Ask the parentified child whether they did the job, and the honest answer is yes. Ask whether they were ready for it, and the answer is no. Both are true, and the impostor feeling lives in the gap between them.
Langford and Clance (1993) traced the impostor’s unrealistic expectations of self to a need for approval left over from desperately trying to please parents. Gregory Jurkovic proposed in 1997 that children who take on adult roles prematurely do so for reasons other than their own needs and competencies: the family needed the role filled, and the child had not grown into it. Castro, Jones and Mirsalimi (2004) studied the link empirically. They described adults carrying a sense of being a fraud, an expectation of impending failure and a fear that hidden inadequacies are always about to be discovered, while striving towards an ideal self that is intelligent and perfect. They also found impostor feelings more likely in families low in support and cohesion, and in families that emphasised intellectual ability and high achievement.

In 2026, Viktória Bodó and Bernadette Kun surveyed 8,433 adults. Parentification and controlling parenting, as the participants remembered them, predicted lower self-esteem and higher perfectionism, which were in turn associated with impostor feelings and with work addiction. The study relied on adults recalling their childhoods, so it cannot establish cause, but its findings match the earlier clinical accounts.
Three features of a parentified childhood feed the feeling directly.
The first is that the competence was never mentored. Where parents keep their position but do not guide the child, the child has to work out both when to step into the parental role and how to perform it, without openly taking over the parent’s authority. Everything is learned by improvising, and skills of unknown origin feel borrowed.
The second is that the work was rarely recognised. Much of what a parentified child does is invisible, the emotional work above all, and families tend to see the child simply as the strong one. Nobody says the job was done well, because nobody acknowledges there was a job. Research has found that whether the child experienced the arrangement as fair, and whether anyone recognised it, matters more than the amount of caregiving (Jankowski et al., 2013; Haxhe, 2016). Recognition is exactly the external confirmation the parentified child went without.
The third is that the child always functioned beyond their developmental range. Operating at a level not yet reached feels like standing on unstable ground, and the sensation outlasts the childhood that produced it. The adult carries it into situations where they are fully equipped, and so feels not good enough despite results that show otherwise.
Why Reassurance Does Not Land
People with impostor feelings are usually surrounded by evidence and reassurance, and both slide off. Praise can even reinforce the old arrangement, in which worth is decided from outside and depends on keeping other people satisfied. Castro and colleagues stated the aim of treatment plainly: reduce the need for external validation and build an internal sense of worth.
The difficulty shows early in therapy. A parentified client told too soon that they are clearly capable will often counter at once with a list of everything going wrong, because accepting the observation would mean giving up an account of inadequacy that has organised their life. Strengths can be named, but tentatively, and only after the person’s own story has been heard. What helps more is a test the person applies for themselves, against criteria that do not depend on anyone’s approval.
Testing the Feeling Against Evidence
A person can feel like a fraud while doing expert work, so confidence cannot serve as the test of expertise. The Subjective Validation of Expertise model sets out five markers a person can check for themselves. They suit the parentified adult especially well, because many of that adult’s skills carry no certificate at all. Organising a household, reading a room, defusing conflict and holding other people’s distress are real skills, learned early, that no course ever validated.
- Teaching. Could you teach the subject comfortably as a second-year university course, with preparation but without having to learn the material first? An introductory course proves nothing either way.
- Current papers. When you read recent work in the field, is most of it familiar, with perhaps 10 to 20 per cent new? Scanning and picking out the new points indicates expertise. Feeling you are studying a whole new subject indicates its absence.
- Framework. Does new information have a place to go? Knowing where it belongs shows at least potential expertise.
- Second-order change. Can you rework, add to or change the frameworks of the field, as well as filling them?
- Flow. When asked a question, does the explanation come out without friction, from knowledge already in place?
Setting the bar in the wrong place stops people from ever passing these tests. A standard far above what the task requires, such as being able to do or supervise a PhD, leaves you permanently short of it, when the reasonable reference point is being able to teach a second-year course. Meeting new material is not the test either, because new material will always appear.
The markers replace the question of whether anyone approves with the question of what the evidence shows, and you are the one asking and answering it.
What the Markers Cannot Do
The markers test the evidence and leave the origin of the feeling untouched. A person can pass all five and still feel, on a bad day, that they are about to be found out.

Some people will also find the markers hard to use. Testing yourself means risking an answer you do not want, which depends on some degree of security. After a childhood spent managing other people’s crises, a pass-or-fail mindset can feel safer than curiosity. That mindset is a protective response, not a flaw in character.
Therapy for parentification works on the origin. It recognises the work the child did and what doing it cost, separates the strengths gained from the harm done, and offers a relationship in which the person is valued for who they are over the function they perform. Alongside that work, the markers give the capable adult a means of checking, on their own terms, whether the expertise is real. For many people it is.
If you recognise yourself as the capable one who has spent years waiting to be found out, and would like to understand where that feeling began, get in touch with Storm’s Edge Therapy.
Sources
Bodó, V., & Kun, B. (2026). Parental control, parentification, and self-evaluative mechanisms in work addiction and impostor phenomenon. International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction. Advance online publication.
Castro, D., Jones, R., & Mirsalimi, H. (2004). Parentification and the impostor phenomenon: An empirical investigation. American Journal of Family Therapy, 32(3), 205-216.
Clance, P. R., & Imes, S. A. (1978). The imposter phenomenon in high achieving women: Dynamics and therapeutic intervention. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 15(3), 241-247.
Haxhe, S. (2016). Parentification and related processes: Distinction and implications for clinical practice. Journal of Family Psychotherapy, 27(3), 185-199.
Jankowski, P. J., Hooper, L. M., Sandage, S. J., & Hannah, N. J. (2013). Parentification and mental health symptoms: Mediator effects of perceived unfairness and differentiation of self. Journal of Family Therapy, 35(1), 43-65.
Jurkovic, G. J. (1997). Lost childhoods: The plight of the parentified child. New York: Brunner/Mazel.
Langford, J., & Clance, P. R. (1993). The imposter phenomenon: Recent research findings regarding dynamics, personality and family patterns and their implications for treatment. Psychotherapy, 30(3), 495-501.
Storms Edge Therapy is a private psychological practice working with adults across the UK and internationally. Our team of clinical and counselling psychologists offers support for a wide range of individual and relational challenges. To find out more or to book an initial consultation, get in touch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is impostor syndrome the same as low confidence or modesty?
No. Modesty is a choice about how you present what you have done, and low confidence is doubt about whether you can do something in the future. The impostor feeling concerns achievements already made, and holds that they were never really yours, so a person can appear outwardly confident and still feel like an impostor.
How can I tell whether my impostor feelings link back to parentification?
Look at the role you held as a child more than at the feeling you have now. If you regularly comforted a parent, kept the peace or made decisions an adult should have made, and nobody treated it as work, the connection is worth exploring. A common sign in adult life is finding it far easier to look after others than to let anyone look after you.
Will the next qualification or promotion make the feeling go away?
Usually not, because each step up brings a new standard to fall short of. Change tends to come from working on where the feeling began and building a sense of worth that does not wait on the next external marker. That work can be done at any age, and the feeling often loosens once the childhood role has been named and understood.




